Why Excel & Spreadsheets Are Not Enough for Quality Management (and What to Use Instead)

For many companies, Excel spreadsheets serve as the go-to tool for tracking quality management processes. They are readily available, cost-effective, and easy to use for basic data entry and analysis. However, as businesses grow and compliance requirements become more complex, relying on spreadsheets for quality management quickly becomes a liability. In this article, we’ll discuss Excel’s limitations in quality management and present a more robust solution: Quality Management System (QMS) software.

Limitations of Using Excel for Quality Management

1. Prone to Human Errors
   • Spreadsheets rely heavily on manual data entry, making them vulnerable to errors such as incorrect values, broken formulas, and misplaced data. A single mistake in a formula or entry can compromise the integrity of an entire dataset, leading to inaccurate reports and compliance issues.
2. Lack of Real-Time Collaboration
   • Quality management involves multiple stakeholders, including quality managers, auditors, and regulatory bodies. Excel lacks real-time collaboration features (without integrating it with cloud storage solutions like OneDrive or SharePoint) leading to version control issues, duplicate data, and miscommunication between teams.
3. Difficulty in Tracking Changes & Audits
   • Audit trails are crucial in quality management, especially for compliance with standards like ISO 9001. Excel does not provide a built-in mechanism to track historical changes, apart from the ‘Track Changes’ feature, which is deprecated and may not be available in newer versions (Excel 365, for instance, hides it by default). This makes it difficult to identify when, how, and by whom modifications were made.
4. Limited Automation & Workflow Capabilities
   • Quality management processes often require a response action, such as triggering corrective actions (CAPA) when issues arise. Excel lacks built-in workflow automation, including the ability to trigger such actions for further processing, requiring users to manually manage notifications, approvals, and process updates.
5. Security Risks & Compliance Challenges
   • Excel files can be easily copied, shared, and edited without proper access control. Sensitive quality data may be exposed to unauthorized users, increasing the risk of data breaches and non-compliance with industry regulations.
6. Scalability Issues
   • As businesses increase in size and scale operations, the task of managing large datasets in Excel spreadsheets increasingly becomes an ineffective process. The limitations of spreadsheets begin to show up as they significantly slow down, crash occasionally, or turn into a complexity that is difficult to manage and maintain effectively. This complexity later translates into inefficiencies that delay quality tracking processes and reporting.

What to Use Instead: Electronic Quality Management System (eQMS) Software

To address these limitations, companies should consider using specialized eQMS software like Trackmedium eQMS. An electronic QMS offers a modern, automated, and secure platform that simplifies and centralizes quality management processes.

Why eQMS Outperforms Excel for Quality Management?

• Easy Workflows Management: Reduce manual effort by managing document approvals, taking corrective actions, and ensuring compliance checks. This is achievable through the utilization of notifications, escalation procedures, and task scheduling.
• Real-Time Collaboration: Enable multiple users to access and update quality data simultaneously, therefore promoting transparency and consistency across all the users involved in the process.
• Audit Trails & Compliance Tracking: A clear and visible history of all changes should be maintained; such that adequate documentation is available for audits as well as for regulatory inspections.
• Data Security & Access Control: Implement access limitations for information based on specific user roles, thereby ensuring that sensitive and confidential information is kept appropriately protected from unauthorized entities.
• Scalability: Handle large datasets efficiently without performance issues.

Conclusion

While Excel is a convenient tool for basic quality tracking, it falls short when managing complex quality processes, compliance requirements, and real-time collaboration. Trackmedium eQMS addresses these challenges by offering a secure, scalable, and feature-rich platform designed specifically for quality management. With automated features, easy workflows, real-time collaboration, and built-in compliance tracking, Trackmedium eQMS ensures that companies can effortlessly manage their quality processes while maintaining regulatory standards. If your company is still relying on spreadsheets, now is the time to transition to a more efficient and compliant solution with Trackmedium eQMS.

^{Image by rawpixel.com on Freepik}